Rumored to be the best manga ever made, Akira Toriyama struck gold when he unleashed dragon ball upon the world captivating many generation which still grows t'ill this day. It's testament goes as far as being an inspiration for the big 3 of shonen manga's: Naruto (Massashi Kishimoto), Bleach (Tite Kubo) and One piece ( Eiichiro Oda).
Being part of the late golden age generation, I was first accustomed to dragon ball z and its Ocean dub when it hit television here in 2001 long enough to remember the sudden transition to the Funimation dub , before dragon ball kai and it's chewed up dub. And before I knew what Dragon Ball GT was...
The Inevitable end
After 325 chapter the story was drawn to an end (pun not intended... at first). It may not have been the best and most fulfilling one but it was the perfect closure we needed; peace was restored for a long time Gohan was married and independent with a promising child and Goku found a new hero who is the reincarnated version of the most ruthless villain, the only one who effectively destroyed the earth!Thus a perfect hero in his second life, kind yet inexperienced and full of power. Though we had a hard time accepting that , Akira Toriyama ensured peace that seemed to last. But with the never ending requests coupled with the creators consent and Funimations opportunity to milk yet another franchise...
Let's face it: when you love something to the point of Nostalgia it becomes hard to admit that it had to end even if the ending was right and satisfying, people will want more at any cause even if it ruins the franchise and what it stood for.
We all know that secretly, the only thing fans wanted was to relive the experience even if forced to choose between moving on or a more plausible alternative. Well, this happens when people aren't careful for what they wish for... 64 episodes of filler.
I think Akira Toriyama realized that you cannot mix two crucial elements while maintaining an exciting story.When the journey ended, Toriyama went another path and choose a more action orientated approach by implementing other worlds and life forms deeming earthlings too weak to spice it up he also indulged his character into the new found dimension. Drifting away from the trusty monkey king to powerful Saiyan Effectively differentiating the two parts of goku's life. Dragon ball GT however, went a different way...
Although there was a debatable superior among the two parts, they where both acknowledged as great due to their respective properties. But what if you could take the best out of both? The answer is: you can't.
By introducing the black-star dragon balls (and pilaf for some reason I can't possibly understand) which turned Goku back into the child he was in the beginning of all saga's, giving him somewhat the same allure as in dragon ball. It is pretty obvious that that such convenience-with the exception of made up dragon ball scattering around the galaxy- did not have any significant impact on Goku or his surrounding. Not only did they have a start, they also had a "re-newed" hero to attrack long time fans. If not for that then why didn't they just keep Uub like intended? And (off-topic) for god's sake why is vegeta's hair flat ?!
Let's face it: when you love something to the point of Nostalgia it becomes hard to admit that it had to end even if the ending was right and satisfying, people will want more at any cause even if it ruins the franchise and what it stood for.
We all know that secretly, the only thing fans wanted was to relive the experience even if forced to choose between moving on or a more plausible alternative. Well, this happens when people aren't careful for what they wish for... 64 episodes of filler.
Grand Tour... Seriously?
Every transition in dragon ball from dragon gang to Z warrior had it's traits. We all enjoyed the journey to find the dragon ball and the friendship and adventure which had Chinese element based on "The journey to the west" as we explored the universe and it's many enemies we had the occasional comical relief be it the odd names (Briefs, pilaf, Oolong) or the perverted hermit. A good writer knows when to sacrifice element for innovative features to ensure the good rating which leads to the following:I think Akira Toriyama realized that you cannot mix two crucial elements while maintaining an exciting story.When the journey ended, Toriyama went another path and choose a more action orientated approach by implementing other worlds and life forms deeming earthlings too weak to spice it up he also indulged his character into the new found dimension. Drifting away from the trusty monkey king to powerful Saiyan Effectively differentiating the two parts of goku's life. Dragon ball GT however, went a different way...
 |
| The Goku in Gt feels like a desperate attempt to recreate the dragon ball journey on a galactic level |
By introducing the black-star dragon balls (and pilaf for some reason I can't possibly understand) which turned Goku back into the child he was in the beginning of all saga's, giving him somewhat the same allure as in dragon ball. It is pretty obvious that that such convenience-with the exception of made up dragon ball scattering around the galaxy- did not have any significant impact on Goku or his surrounding. Not only did they have a start, they also had a "re-newed" hero to attrack long time fans. If not for that then why didn't they just keep Uub like intended? And (off-topic) for god's sake why is vegeta's hair flat ?!
Thoug it was "supervised" by Akira Toriyama it did not mean it was his work, the only thing memorable added to the mix that could be credited to him was the super saiyan 4 form which was beyond believe.
GT went to far and contradicted the original work by forcing important characters who settled down in the peaceful years to take up the mantel as earth protector once again. Not only does it feel cheap it also has consequences on your image of the said characters in the original work, like Trunks & Goten who I can't stand in GT and because of it cannot 'un-link' the image of the young duo in Dragon ball z and their unfortunate aftermath. It was ridiculously obvious that the younger generation was more interesting by the teenage life than battle, but due to the incomplete list of active Z- warriors and active saiyans left at the end of chapter 425 they had to improvise and make one dysfunctional group of fighters who were extra's for the only 2 characters who mattered, I don't even have to mention their names it is that obvious.
That is it... I may hit some nerves I may get some positive feedback, but I'm only describing the obvious. Do comment about your own view, It would be appreciated.
GT went to far and contradicted the original work by forcing important characters who settled down in the peaceful years to take up the mantel as earth protector once again. Not only does it feel cheap it also has consequences on your image of the said characters in the original work, like Trunks & Goten who I can't stand in GT and because of it cannot 'un-link' the image of the young duo in Dragon ball z and their unfortunate aftermath. It was ridiculously obvious that the younger generation was more interesting by the teenage life than battle, but due to the incomplete list of active Z- warriors and active saiyans left at the end of chapter 425 they had to improvise and make one dysfunctional group of fighters who were extra's for the only 2 characters who mattered, I don't even have to mention their names it is that obvious.
That is it... I may hit some nerves I may get some positive feedback, but I'm only describing the obvious. Do comment about your own view, It would be appreciated.
Also...
 |
| If you enjoyed this, you have no right to call the Garlic -and any other filler- bad |
M.
No comments:
Post a Comment